# The best pizza in New York City

Coal-oven classics, Neapolitan pies and the slices New Yorkers queue for, according to Time Out, Tasting Table, food critics and Yelp.

- 734 votes · 16 items
- Oct 24, 2025 · erin_suitcase
- https://even.best/en/l/170/the-best-pizza-in-new-york-city

## Top 15

1. **Di Fara Pizza** (82 · ▲86 ▼4) — Midwood, Brooklyn institution opened in 1965 by Dom DeMarco, regularly named the city's best.
2. **Una Pizza Napoletana** (62 · ▲68 ▼6) — Anthony Mangieri's Lower East Side pizzeria with naturally leavened dough, ranked among the world's best.
3. **John's of Bleecker Street** (52 · ▲57 ▼5) — Coal-oven pies by the whole pie only, in the West Village since 1929.
4. **L'Industrie Pizzeria** (52 · ▲56 ▼4) — Williamsburg slice shop opened in 2015, famous for its burrata slice.
5. **Joe's Pizza** (35 · ▲45 ▼10) — Classic Greenwich Village slice joint since 1975.
6. **Juliana's** (33 · ▲35 ▼2) — Patsy Grimaldi's coal-oven pizzeria under the Brooklyn Bridge in DUMBO.
7. **Lucali** (28 · ▲32 ▼4) — Candlelit Carroll Gardens pizzeria with long waits and no reservations.
8. **Joe & Pat's** (27 · ▲31 ▼4) — Staten Island family pizzeria since 1960, known for paper-thin crusts.
9. **Lombardi's** (23 · ▲32 ▼9) — Little Italy pizzeria licensed in 1905, often called America's first pizzeria.
10. **Scarr's Pizza** (23 · ▲29 ▼6) — Lower East Side slice shop that mills its own flour in-house.
11. **Rubirosa** (22 · ▲31 ▼9) — Nolita Italian-American restaurant famous for its thin-crust vodka pie.
12. **Prince Street Pizza** (22 · ▲28 ▼6) — Nolita slice shop known for its square pepperoni slice with crispy cups.
13. **Arturo's Coal Oven Pizza** (20 · ▲28 ▼8) — Greenwich Village fixture since 1957 with live jazz.
14. **Totonno's** (19 · ▲27 ▼8) — Coney Island coal-oven pizzeria open since 1924.
15. **L&B Spumoni Gardens** (18 · ▲26 ▼8) — Gravesend, Brooklyn spot since 1939, famous for its Sicilian square and spumoni.
16. **Mama's Too!** (10 · ▲20 ▼10) — Upper West Side slice shop known for its crispy square slices.

How is this ranking ordered? By people's votes: each ▲ adds a point and each ▼ takes one away. Anyone can vote and add what is missing.