The best pizza in New York City
The top 3 according to 734 votes from people: Di Fara Pizza · Una Pizza Napoletana · John's of Bleecker Street. (Updated Oct 24, 2025.)
Coal-oven classics, Neapolitan pies and the slices New Yorkers queue for, according to Time Out, Tasting Table, food critics and Yelp.
Top 15
-
1
Di Fara Pizza
Midwood, Brooklyn institution opened in 1965 by Dom DeMarco, regularly named the city's best.
-
2
Una Pizza Napoletana
Anthony Mangieri's Lower East Side pizzeria with naturally leavened dough, ranked among the world's best.
-
3
John's of Bleecker Street
Coal-oven pies by the whole pie only, in the West Village since 1929.
-
4
L'Industrie Pizzeria
Williamsburg slice shop opened in 2015, famous for its burrata slice.
-
5
Joe's Pizza
Classic Greenwich Village slice joint since 1975.
-
6
Juliana's
Patsy Grimaldi's coal-oven pizzeria under the Brooklyn Bridge in DUMBO.
-
7
Lucali
Candlelit Carroll Gardens pizzeria with long waits and no reservations.
-
8
Joe & Pat's
Staten Island family pizzeria since 1960, known for paper-thin crusts.
-
9
Lombardi's
Little Italy pizzeria licensed in 1905, often called America's first pizzeria.
-
10
Scarr's Pizza
Lower East Side slice shop that mills its own flour in-house.
-
11
Rubirosa
Nolita Italian-American restaurant famous for its thin-crust vodka pie.
-
12
Prince Street Pizza
Nolita slice shop known for its square pepperoni slice with crispy cups.
-
13
Arturo's Coal Oven Pizza
Greenwich Village fixture since 1957 with live jazz.
-
14
Totonno's
Coney Island coal-oven pizzeria open since 1924.
-
15
L&B Spumoni Gardens
Gravesend, Brooklyn spot since 1939, famous for its Sicilian square and spumoni.
Candidates
They don't make it into the top 15… yet. Vote for them to move them up.
-
16
Mama's Too!
Upper West Side slice shop known for its crispy square slices.
How is this ranking ordered? By people's votes: each ▲ adds a point and each ▼ takes one away. Anyone can vote and add what is missing.
Is something missing?
Comments (8)
Una Pizza Napoletana is better than anything I had in Naples, honestly
Joe's is overrated, it's just a regular slice
A regular slice done perfectly is exactly the point of Joe's.
L'Industrie's burrata slice is the best slice in the city right now
Scarr's mills their own flour, you can taste the difference
Spumoni Gardens square slice on a summer day 😍
Lucali in Carroll Gardens, get there at 4pm to put your name down. Worth it.
Di Fara at #1 is the right answer even with the wait. Dom DeMarco was a legend. RIP.