Skip to content
even.best

The best Xbox games

The top 3 according to 241 votes from people: Halo: Combat Evolved · Ninja Gaiden Black · Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell. (Updated May 24, 2024.)

The 25 Xbox games with the highest critic scores on Metacritic, the weighted average of professional reviews. Expansions and compilations left out.

brian.austin · · 26 items · 241 votes · 1 comment · updated May 24, 2024

Top 20

  1. 1

    Halo: Combat Evolved

    Released November 2001. Metascore: 97.

    ▲ 25 ▼ 2

    23
  2. 2

    Ninja Gaiden Black

    Released September 2005. Metascore: 94.

    ▲ 18 ▼ 0

    18
  3. 3

    Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell

    Released November 2002. Metascore: 93.

    ▲ 12 ▼ 0

    12
  4. 4

    Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic

    Released July 2003. Metascore: 94.

    ▲ 11 ▼ 0

    11
  5. 5

    Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow

    Released March 2004. Metascore: 93.

    ▲ 11 ▼ 1

    10
  6. 6

    Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

    Released June 2005. Metascore: 93.

    ▲ 11 ▼ 1

    10
  7. 7

    Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory

    Released March 2005. Metascore: 94.

    ▲ 11 ▼ 2

    9
  8. 8

    Halo 2

    Released November 2004. Metascore: 95.

    ▲ 9 ▼ 2

    7
  9. 9

    SoulCalibur II

    Released August 2003. Metascore: 92.

    ▲ 9 ▼ 2

    7
  10. 10

    Project Gotham Racing 2

    Released November 2003. Metascore: 90.

    ▲ 8 ▼ 2

    6
  11. 11

    Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3

    Released March 2002. Metascore: 93.

    ▲ 7 ▼ 1

    6
  12. 12

    Forza Motorsport (2005)

    Released May 2005. Metascore: 92.

    ▲ 6 ▼ 0

    6
  13. 13

    SSX 3

    Released October 2003. Metascore: 92.

    ▲ 8 ▼ 3

    5
  14. 14

    NCAA Football 2003

    Released July 2002. Metascore: 90.

    ▲ 7 ▼ 2

    5
  15. 15

    ESPN NFL Football

    Released September 2003. Metascore: 91.

    ▲ 6 ▼ 1

    5
  16. 16

    Madden NFL 2003

    Released August 2002. Metascore: 92.

    ▲ 7 ▼ 3

    4
  17. 17

    Madden NFL 2004

    Released August 2003. Metascore: 92.

    ▲ 5 ▼ 1

    4
  18. 18

    Madden NFL 2005

    Released August 2004. Metascore: 91.

    ▲ 5 ▼ 1

    4
  19. 19

    Ninja Gaiden (2004)

    Released March 2004. Metascore: 91.

    ▲ 5 ▼ 1

    4
  20. 20

    Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time

    Released November 2003. Metascore: 92.

    ▲ 5 ▼ 2

    3

Candidates

They don't make it into the top 20… yet. Vote for them to move them up.

  1. 21

    Half-Life 2

    Released November 2005. Metascore: 90.

    ▲ 4 ▼ 1

    3
  2. 22

    Burnout 3: Takedown

    Released September 2004. Metascore: 94.

    ▲ 4 ▼ 2

    2
  3. 23

    Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 4

    Released October 2002. Metascore: 90.

    ▲ 4 ▼ 2

    2
  4. 24

    Fable

    Lionhead Studios' 2004 action RPG where your choices shaped your hero's looks and reputation in Albion.

    Added by Joshua Kim · ▲ 2 ▼ 0

    2
  5. 25

    ESPN NFL 2K5

    Released July 2004. Metascore: 92.

    ▲ 2 ▼ 2

    0
  6. 26

    Panzer Dragoon Orta

    Released January 2003. Metascore: 90.

    ▲ 2 ▼ 3

    -1

How is this ranking ordered? By people's votes: each ▲ adds a point and each ▼ takes one away. Anyone can vote and add what is missing.

Is something missing?

Log in to add an item

Comments (1)

Log in to comment

Joshua Kim

Where's Fable? That game was all anyone talked about in 2004.

More rankings like this