The best ice cream brands in America
The top 3 according to 45 votes from people: Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams · Tillamook · Häagen-Dazs. (Updated Jul 24, 2026.)
Supermarket and premium ice cream brands that win blind taste tests (Smarter Ranking 2026, The Kitchn, Saveur) and top Instacart's sales. Tillamook and Häagen-Dazs lead.
Top 10
-
1
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
Columbus cult brand since 2002, with a buttercream base and adventurous flavours.
-
2
Tillamook
Oregon creamery ice cream with about 13.5% butterfat; top score (90) in 2026 testing.
-
3
Häagen-Dazs
15% butterfat and low overrun; its vanilla is the store-bought gold standard.
-
4
Ben & Jerry's
Vermont's king of chunky mix-ins, from Cherry Garcia to Phish Food.
-
5
Salt & Straw
Portland brand with inventive seasonal flavours.
-
6
Van Leeuwen
Brooklyn ice cream with a French egg-yolk base.
-
7
Blue Bell
Texas favourite famous for Homemade Vanilla.
-
8
Breyers
Classic brand among Instacart's top five best-sellers.
-
9
Halo Top
Light, high-protein pints among the top five on Instacart.
-
10
Talenti
Gelato in clear jars.
Candidates
They don't make it into the top 10… yet. Vote for them to move them up.
-
11
Graeter's
Cincinnati French pot ice cream with giant chocolate chunks.
How is this ranking ordered? By people's votes: each ▲ adds a point and each ▼ takes one away. Anyone can vote and add what is missing.
Is something missing?
Comments (5)
Graeter's black raspberry chip is elite.
Tillamook first, absolutely.
Jeni's brown butter almond brittle, worth the price.
Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla, Texas pride.
Tillamook at #1 is correct, their Marionberry Pie is incredible.